While
traveling on my summer holidays, I visited some
folks who had bought large screen TVs. Since I
still am hanging on to my old 21 inch Sony, I had
a chance to learn a few things about these new
(and expensive) toys.
First of all, some people with big screen
TVs think they are automatically getting an
HDTV image. But at least some are in the know
enough to realize they have to get a special
box for HD signals from satellite or cable
and pay extra for the few available channels
with limited scheduling. I saw some Olympic
events on HD and it was quite impressive -
images which would motivate people to purchase
a wide screen TV. But the Olympic programming
was not up to date and limited to certain events.
NBC kept running an impressive sequence of
aerials of Greece as a trailer / filler. Of
course, no one can rent HD movies yet, so the
potential of enjoying HD is severely limited
until things get moving towards a more complete
HD distribution.
But my main concern relating to my cinematographer’s
craft was the 4x3 pictures coming from all
the other channels. The NTSC pictures are blown
up way too much by these 50 to 70 inch screens.
I would think that viewers should at least
set the screen up for 4x3 with bars on the
side, but when I mentioned that to them - they
didn’t get the picture - ordinary viewers
have a lot of problems with the concept of
screen formats - they just feel cheated when
they see extra black bars. So, they use the
4x3 expanded option to fill the screen they
paid so much for. This results in extra top
and bottom cutoff and stretched images that
make the actors instantly gain a lot of extra
weight. Some sets have an different expanded
setting which keeps the center area normal
and expands the edges only, which gives a weird
fish eye effect on pans. Not only do viewers
want to fill the screen, but some have been
told by installers or instruction manuals that
they should not use any setting which shows
black bars because the screens will memorize
the edge line - so why bother offering that
option?! Even on letterboxed DVDs (or broadcast
letterbox shows) viewers want to eliminate
the top and bottom borders, so they use a 4x3
blow up setting, which of course cuts the sides
and blows up NTSC even more.
So all this means that big screen viewers
are looking at Standard Def pictures blown
up beyond resolution limits and with much more
cutoff than was ever intended! This phenomenon
will be around for awhile I fear - it’s
something we never had with regular TVs - viewers
could never play around with the framing as
much before. These new TVs offer too much abuse
of our carefully composed pictures! From now
on, better set your safe action at 70% or less!
Richard Stringer CSC
|